Ranking Costco Ice Cream by Brand and Flavor

Who doesn’t have an ice cream shelf in their freezer? You never know when you will want a frozen treat at night, so we encourage stocking up on Costco ice cream the next time you’re at a warehouse. Like so many items in Costco, the variety of choices can be overwhelming. To help plan your next Costco haul, we’ve ranked the top Costco ice cream by brand and flavor. From Häagen-Dazs to Nestlé, there are tons of delicious treats at our favorite wholesaler. 

Related: What Is the Best Costco Frozen Food for Families?

13. Mavens Durian Ice Cream

Our first Costco ice cream selection is both viral from Shark Tank in 2019 and slightly controversial because of its flavor. Mavens Durian Ice Cream is made with real durian pulp, giving it the signature taste and aromatic smell of the fruit. The durian, also known as “the king of fruits,” is popular in Southeast Asia and is covered in a spiky shell. This flavor will not appeal to everyone, but for those who like durian fruit, it’s such an irreplaceable treat. Because of its unique main ingredient, it is usually only available in West Coast Costcos.

12. Halo Top Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

With only 110 calories per serving, Halo Top Peanut Butter Cup ice cream provides a light option for those who have a persistent sweet tooth. Peanut butter is one of the top flavors from Halo Top for its subtle sweetness. This Costco ice cream is only available in select stores, so be sure to check your local Costco and see if they have this frozen treat. 

11. Twix Ice Cream Bars, Caramel and Cookies

If you enjoy the combination of caramel, cookies, chocolate, and ice cream in a Twix candy bar, elevate your snacking with the Twix Ice Cream Bars. Each package contains 24 bars, which happen to be completely kosher. Customers love the combination of cookies, caramel, and ice cream in each bite.

10. Brothers Mint Bon Bons

You might want to keep the next Costco ice cream item for yourself. Brothers Mint Ice Cream Bonbons are a fun way to enjoy ice cream with only calories per bonbon. Each bonbon is filled with mint ice cream and dipped in dark chocolate. Customers enjoy the combination of mint and chocolate flavors which makes this treat as refreshing as it is decadent. These are not always available at Costco, so make sure to grab a pack if you see them at your local store. 

9. Fat Boy Ice Cream Sandwiches

If you are craving an ice cream sandwich to curb your sweet tooth, then try Fat Boy’s Ice Cream Sandwiches. Customers enjoy the creamy texture of the vanilla ice cream combined with the chocolate cookie sandwich. The package comes with eighteen sandwiches that are made with real cream, fresh whole milk, and Madagascar vanilla beans. 

Check Out: How Many Costco Stores Are There in the U.S.?

8. Kirkland Signature Ice Cream Bars

One of the top products in Costco’s featured brand, Kirkland Signature, is these Chocolate Almond Dipped Vanilla Ice Cream Bars. The bars are dipped in chocolate and almonds for a crunchy outside coating surrounding the vanilla ice cream. Often compared to Häagen-Dazs ice cream bars, these are a cheaper, but just as delicious. 

7. It’s-It Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches

Producing ice cream treats since 1928, It’s-It Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches have been popular for decades. Different than traditional ice cream sandwiches, each one is made with vanilla ice cream and oatmeal cookies all dipped in dark chocolate. And if you’re trying to keep dessert light, each sandwich is only 170 calories. 

Also Read: Top Household Items You Should Buy at Costco to Save Money

6. Häagen-Dazs Ice Cream Chocolate

You cannot go wrong with Häagen-Dazs classic Chocolate Ice Cream. Prizing the quality and simplicity of their ice cream, their chocolate flavor has only five ingredients: cream, sugar, concentrated skim milk, liquid egg yolk, and cocoa. As one of the best Costco ice cream flavors, customers enjoy the richness without any of the chocolate bitter taste. 

5. Nestlé Drumstick Ice Cream Sundae Cones

Recognizable from popular TV commercials, Nestlé Drumsticks are a fun treat with ice cream, chocolate, and peanuts all stacked onto a cone. Costco’s ice cream section sells these drumsticks in a variety pack, so you can enjoy three flavors: vanilla fudge, vanilla caramel, and original vanilla. This is a perfect option for both adults and kids. 

Check Out: 20 Best Things to Buy at Costco for a Bargain

4. Snickers Ice Cream Bars, Caramel & Peanuts

Similar to Twix, Snickers has its own brand of ice cream bars, with 24 bars in each box. Instead of just vanilla, the ice cream within each bar is peanut butter flavored, pairing quite nicely with the caramel and peanuts on top. Each bar contains 180 calories.

3. Häagen-Dazs Ice Cream Vanilla

Of course, we cannot have a Costco ice cream round-up without having Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Ice Cream on it. Similar to other Häagen-Dazs ice cream, there are five ingredients: cream, skim milk, cane sugar, egg yolks, and vanilla extract (from Madagascar vanilla beans). Customers love the taste as it is the perfect example of classic, vanilla ice cream and you can add it to any treat. 

2. Nestlé Frozen Dairy Dessert Variety Pack

Nestlé offers several variety ice cream packs at Costco, and this particular one contains drumsticks, vanilla sandwiches, and cookie-dipped bars. There are 40 total bars inside the package, which is a perfect pack to stock up on before a birthday party or barbecue. In addition, the drumsticks are offered in three flavors: vanilla, vanilla caramel, and chocolate. This is a perfect way to get several Nestlé products for a low price. 

Read More: 10 Best Protein Bars at Costco

1. Kirkland Signature Super Premium Ice Cream Vanilla

Our last, and arguably best, Costco ice cream product is from the Kirkland Signature brand. Each box of the Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream contains two half-gallon containers for a great price, often cheaper than buying two separate cartons of ice cream. Customers love the rich and creamy flavor, and you can be assured that Kirkland’s brand always provides quality ice cream.

Costco sells a variety of Kirkland Signature and other name-brand ice cream products. Whether it’s an ice cream sandwich or ice cream scooped from a tub, Costco provides quality flavors at cheaper prices so you can always stock up on a late-night frozen treat. Next time you’re shopping at Costco, add some of these items to your list.

And if you’re a Costco regular, comment below which one is your favorite!