What’s the Best Cheese in Costco? Here Are Our 14 Favorite Cheeses

Cabot Creamery is a well-known brand in many stores, including Costco warehouses. While the brand supplies many varieties, the Seriously Sharp Cheddar is a favorite amongst customers. The cheese has a nice flavor without the overpowering sharpness and is a great choice if you need an all-purpose cheese. You can use the 2-pound bar for snacking with apples and crackers, shredded over chili, or sandwiched for a grilled cheese.

Read More: 7 Best Costco Deals Right Now

Elevate your cheese game with this Dutch Tradition Gouda imported from Holland. This large hunk of cheese is perfect for party platters or melting over your signature dish. The creamy cheese is mild for a gouda and its soft texture is great for melting and appeals to most cheese lovers. This is one of the many reasons why it’s one of the best cheeses in Costco.

Beloved by many Costco shoppers, consider buying Dodoni’s Feta Cheese in Brine the next time you head to the warehouse. Imported from Greece, this feta is salty and tangy. Each container has slabs of feta in brine so it doesn’t dry out like the crumbled variety. If you enjoy feta, you may even eat a slab with a drizzle of olive oil and bread, as the taste is just that good.

Check Out: 7 Best Costco Nut Butters for Healthy Snacking

Shredded mozarella may be delicious, but the fresh is unbeatable in flavor. Belgioioso’s Fresh Mozzarella can be a tasty addition to homemade pizzas, pasta bakes, caprese platters, and more. Costco sells the cheese in a two-pack that weighs one pound, filled with pre-cut slices that can be enjoyed right out of the bag. If you want another way to snack, try it with a few drops of balsamic glaze.

Gruyere is a firm yellow Swiss cheese that is rich, creamy, and salty. It’s a great addition to your mac and cheese but is also wonderful paired with smoked meats. And now you can grab a one-pound block of Emmi Le Gruyere to try for yourself. The package is not only gluten-free but is also lactose-free, a great option for a range of customers. 

Known for their butter, Kerrygold is an Irish brand that also makes delicious cheese. The two-pound block is made from grass-fed cows and is 100% natural. The flavor is similar to parmesan and cheddar with a hard, slightly gritty texture since the aging process allows crystals to form. It’s a versatile choice to slice, grate, or even melt down. 

Read more: 8 Best Costco Spices and Seasonings for Home Chefs

Snack on cheese on the go thanks to Tillamook’s individually packaged cheese slices. This makes a great addition to your refrigerator for both kids and yourself for an easy snack throughout the day. A package comes with 52 individually wrapped medium cheddar cheese slices, perfect for packed lunches or a boost of protein — each one contains five grams.  

One of the best cheeses in Costco is Cypress Grove’s goat cheese. Goat cheese isn’t for everyone but this mini one-pound portion is perfect for taste testing. Its flavor is bitter, tart, and tangy, and pairs well with spicy jams or creamy soups.  

Related: 8 Best Costco Organic Items for a Healthier Lifestyle

Cheddar is one of the most common cheeses you can pick up. But this Kirkland Signature Coastal Cheddar is aged for more than a year, elevating it from the basic white or yellow cheddar you get at other stores. It has a rich and slightly sweet flavor that is great for charcuterie boards or sliced up for sandwiches. 
[tpd-feed-follow post_id=”49578″]

Manchego cheese got its name from the Manchego sheep it’s made from. The two-pound block is aged for six months and produced in Spain. The semi-hard cheese is a great addition to your charcuterie board, and thanks to its mild, earthy flavor, it pairs well with salty items like olives and cured meat. It can also be a wonderful addition to recipes like sandwiches or quesadillas. 

Check out: 8 Best Frozen Foods for Your Air Fryer at Costco

The best cheese in Costco for tangy and tart lovers is their Organic Feta cheese. Feta is a staple for several Mediterranean-inspired dishes, from Greek salads to baked feta pasta. Paired with fruit, feta is even a great addition to desserts such as fruit tarts. Snag one of these 28-ounce containers of this crumbly, yet creamy cheese the next time you’re at Costco. 

Want to impress your guests at your next get-together? Then check out BellaVitano’s Cabernet Sauvignon cheese. To make a statement, this is the best cheese in Costco you can add to a charcuterie board. With a unique flavor profile, you’ll want to keep buying it. The block is similar to parmesan but with a hint of butteriness. You can slice or crumble this cheese and of course, it pairs well with wine like Pinot Noir or Merlot. 

Related: 9 Best Keto Products at Costco

One cheese in Costco that receives a lot of love and praise is Kirkland Signature’s Imported French Brie. The creamy, luxurious, rich, and buttery cheese has an earthy tone that channels a classic brie. Similar to goat cheese, brie stands out when paired with fruits, like jams or jellies — especially on cheese boards. Or, try it on a sandwich with caramelized onions and you’ll never turn back. 

Finally, the best cheese in Costco is by far their Parmigiano Reggiano. Not only is it delicious in flavor, but it is also arguably one of the most popular items in Costco overall. It comes in block form as well as shredded, but most Costco customers prefer the block. The two-pound aged block can last you a while, providing nutty parmesan for any Italian meal at home. 

Read more: 8 Best Costco Protein Snacks for Post-Workout Recovery

Have you tried these Costco cheeses? Which one is your favorite? Let us know in the comments your thoughts and recommendations. 

Keep checking back here at Costco97 for information on the best deals and hidden sales like .97 discounts. We talk about the best Costco bargains, secret hacks, and everything there is to know about the wholesaler and being a part of their membership. And be sure to stay in touch with the upcoming coupons, listed in our Costco Coupon Book (updated monthly).